With the rise in the popularity of any branded expensive product, there inevitably follows a surge in the production and immediate mass consumption of its fake versions. These clever knockoffs are meticulously made and insidiously hard to distinguish from genuine products and styles.
A prime example of this trend was when $500 Frye Campus boots found their dupes lining the shelves at Target for a mere $50. These replicas may not carry the same prestige as their high-end counterparts. Still, they make fashion more accessible to the common man, offering an affordable way for fashion enthusiasts to enjoy similar looks and trends.
About Frye Campus Boots
Handcrafted in the USA, these boots scream style! Premium full-grain leather is durable, and a 13’’-14’’ inch tall shaft with minimal yet intricate detailing makes them versatile. The Frye Campus Boots have become insanely popular in recent years thanks to social media platforms like TikTok.
Celebrities such as Olivia Rodrigo, Addison Rae, and Zendaya have been spotted wearing them, further escalating their status as just a fashion icon. As Glamour put it, there was a “cultish level of obsession” surrounding these high-end fashion boots, people going relentlessly crazy over their style and trend, and it’s easy to see why. Retailing at around $500, they have graced the closets of style icons, influencers, and modern cowgirls alike.
But for many, the price tag is the barrier. So, let’s be honest. Do I want a pair myself? Sure! But am I willing to spend half a grand on a pair of boots? Absolutely not.
Here are some dupes that are affordable and impressively convincing, too! It’s perfect for any fashion lover who wants to stay on-trend, stay comfortable, and stay smart about their spending at the same time.
Top 8 Frye Campus Boots Alternatives
Dandelie Camel Boots – Latigo
Price: $279
The Dandelie Camel Boots – Latigo are a striking match for Frye’s Campus Boots and are available in a warm, earthy camel tone that closely mimics the banana shade of the original called Campus 14L (in banana). Why is it a great dupe? Its visual similarity recreates the long-legged Frye look. With its tall shaft, curved top, sleek, minimalistic style, and a low block heel, they are just an ideal pair!
Pros:
- For less than a fifth of the price, you get the style without draining your bank account.
- Equally stylish, trendy, and most importantly, comfortable.
- The faux leather is animal-friendly and more breathable.
- Easy to replace with changing trends and seasons, making them a friendly and low-commitment addition to your wardrobe.
Cons:
- They are not made from real leather; you may have to compromise slightly on the authentic feel and durability.
- It may not age as gracefully as the original; hence, the quality of the aging process decreases.
- The sole and the heel may wear faster
Schuh Damari Leather Pull-On Boots – Black
Price: $126
The Schuh Damari Leather Pull-On Boots are as timeless as Frye, or at least they look it! The design features and aesthetics mirror the Frye Campus boots, making them a good option. These, too, are knee-high length, just without the heavy price tag, making them a compelling deal. So if you are looking for an iconic alternative, look no further!
Pros:
- Extremely affordable price range, making them accessible to wider audiences
- Made from leather sourced from LWG-certified tanneries, supporting environmentally responsible manufacturing.
- Comfortable wear, and easy to style
Cons:
- The style is more understated, leaning less towards the original’s standard vintage and rugged charm.
The Blondo Tessa Waterproof Boot
Price: $219
The Blondo Tessa Waterproof Boots are what one might call the perfect blend of fashion and function. It’s more of a practical Frye Campus Boots dupe. The Aqua Protect technology promises waterproofing and stain resistance, making it your go-to pair in unpredictable weather. A wet wipe across, and they are clean as new.
Pros:
- A 15’’ shaft height and a 12’’ shaft circumference give an uncanny resemblance to the original.
- Stylish design with a stacked heel and a comfortable fit with textile lining and insole
- Waterproof construction with the AquaProtect seal
Cons
- At $219, it may still be considered a significant investment to some.
- While the suede finish looks sleek, it’s not real leather, lacking the long-term durability.
Ralph Lauren – Maskin Burnished Leather Boot
Price: $159
Ralph Lauren, in itself, is a legendary name in fashion. This can’t be labelled as a random dupe, but an alternative offered by a premium brand in its own right. It is no less than Frye, even better, with a long-standing reputation for craftsmanship and quality. The Maskin Boot is made from Burnished leather and offers a more polished and equestrian-inspired wear. Its overall design mirrors Frye’s signature tall shaft and timeless look, making it a worthy visual dupe.
Pros:
- Brand name—Ralph Lauren—speaks for itself! You still get a brand product in the name of a dupe.
- Caters to both casual and dressier looks with a versatile aesthetic.
- Burnished Leather finish gives it a premium, rich look, much like that of Frye’s
Cons:
- Some will not have a major price drop; you will still pay for the label and quality.
- The break-in period might create a problem as the style requires some time to become comfortable (as is the case with Frye, too)
- Ralph Lauren is known to focus more on aesthetics than on overall quality. Aims to combine luxury and style
The Söfft Shelby Boot
Price: $170
The Söfft Shelby Boots in all their glory are beautiful and extremely chic. It resembles the Frye Campus’s high-quality leather construction and a tall shaft with a comfort-focused design. It is a suitable dupe for those seeking style and practicality! Though it lacks the vintage Frye look, it is definitely a fashion-forward alternative.
Pros:
- Weather-resistant is designed to keep your feet dry in rain or snow.
- Comfortable fit, stylish design, and versatility.
- Seam-sealed for water resistance, flexible, and slip-resistant TPR outsole.
Cons:
- No returns are being accepted after the product’s sale (currently).
The JOKACEAR Banana Women’s Chunky Casual Boot (Pink)
Price: $65
This replica of the Frye Campus Boots is being sold on Amazon for a very affordable price. The JOKACEAR Women’s Knee High Boots Chunky Casual boots in pink are a literal twin sister to the Frye Campus 14L in Pink! It’s visually comparable and a budget-friendly alternative. This product seems to have attracted enough attention for Amazon to declare it a bestseller. Those looking for affordable options should definitely go for it!
Pros:
- The visual similarity is striking.
- Available in a pink hue with brown heel, they align with the pink variant of the Frye Campus, catering to those seeking that specific colour (which might be a large audience considering the Pookie trend)
- Those with a prime account will have added convenience with a fast and hassle-free delivery of the product
Cons:
- The synthetic quality is nowhere near what the original stands for.
- Lacks the durability and aging characteristics of genuine leather
- JOKACEAR is not a very well-known brand. Its obscurity raises concerns when it’s directly compared to brands like Frye
UBWDU Platform Square Toe Chunky Campus Boot
Price: $64
An overall budget-friendly option to the Frye Campus Boots, these alternatives are great if you wish to wear trendy fashion every day. If the potential buyers don’t mind trade-offs in material quality and brand reliability, these options are viable! Effortlessly delivers a similar aesthetic without the premium price tag.
Pros:
- The boot features a tall shaft and chunky heel mirroring the silhouette of Frye Campus 14L
- Significantly lower price than the original, good option for budget-conscious consumers
- Available in many colour shades, aligning with the earthy tones of the Frye Campus
- It’s vegan-friendly, as the use of synthetic products eliminates animal cruelty
Cons:
- Compromise in the material quality
- UBWDU is a relatively unknown brand, which may raise concerns about quality assurance and customer service.
The Mia Kolt Silver Boot
Price: $77
The Mia Kolt Silver Boot is a sparkling knee-high western-style boot that is just perfect! With its cowboy elements, pointed toe, tonal stitching, a 13.4’’ shaft, and a metallic finish, it impersonates the Frye Campus 14L in silver rather flawlessly. An ideal model for those who deviate from the mainstream fashion colours, such as black and brown, and lean more towards the metallic beauties!
Pros:
- The metallic silver finish adds a modern flair to the vintage boot style, just as the design of Frye also aims to achieve
- Side pull tabs and a zippered closure make putting on and taking off convenient.
- The faux leather lining provides comfort and a durable outsole
Cons:
- There are material limitations due to its construction of faux leather, as they lack the longevity of genuine leather boots
- Currently available in silver and ivory, it may limit colour options.
- The aesthetic is more Western than classical
Reformation Nancy Knee Boot – Black Leather
Price: $448
The Nancy Knee Boot offers a sleek, contemporary take on the classic knee-high boot. Though not as rugged in its appearance as the original, it is made from calf leather and follows the minimalistic design. The boot echoes the timeless Frye Campus 14L Boot (in black), offering a similar look with a modern twist. The aesthetics that both these products seek are very similar. Though the price drop is very slight, it’s an excellent choice for those seeking a stylish alternative.
Pros:
- Made with LWG-certified leather results in a lower environmental impact
- A major part of the Reformation’s carbon-neutral and circular fashion initiatives
- Ideal for both casual and elegant looks
- Compared to Frye’s thick and stiff leather, the calf leather is softer, providing more comfort.
Cons:
- Doesn’t have the heritage appeal of Frye’s vintage Americana stitching and legacy quality.
Buying Guide: How to Pick the Right Frye Campus Boot Alternative?
We get it — not everyone’s ready to drop half a paycheck on a pair of boots, no matter how dreamy they look. That’s why picking the right dupe matters. Here’s what to keep in mind before you hit add to cart:
- Feel the material – Look for genuine leather if possible, it ages better and wears beautifully over time. However, good quality faux leather also works
- Heel and sole quality – A good dupe should have a sturdy sole and a solid heel — nothing wobbly or paper thin.
- Comfort should come first. There is no point in looking cute if you’re limping by the end of the day. Look for cushioned insoles and arch support.
- Price vs. Value – While saving money is great, investing more in a higher quality dupe sometimes pays off in the long run. A slightly pricier alternative made of better materials can outlast a very cheap one by years.
- Eco-friendliness – Some modern brands offer eco-friendly options from recycled or low-impact materials.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Frye Campus boots worth the price?
Frye Campus boots are made with premium American leather, Goodyear welt construction, and classic craftsmanship, making them a long-term investment. However, if your wallet doesn’t agree, quality dupes can still offer a similar look and longevity.
What should I look for in a good Frye Campus alternative?
Pay attention to the material (genuine or high-grade faux leather), construction quality (stitching, sole, heel), and comfort features. A good dupe should not just look like the original but also feel sturdy and supportive.
How long do dupe boots usually last?
Depends on how rough you are with them. A good dupe can easily last you a few seasons if you take care of it (aka don’t stomp through puddles daily).
How do I style these alternatives?
These boots are timeless for a reason (they go with everything!) Wear them with denim skirts, prairie dresses, flared jeans, or cozy fall sweaters. Think effortless cowgirl, but make it fashion. Add a straw hat, and the look will be complete!
Conclusion
The Frye Campus Boots are, without a doubt, a real deal. But if you are after the look and not the splurge, these alternatives definitely deliver! Throw these amazing boots on with a frilled skirt, a tucked-in blouse, and a bold smoky eye, and you’ve got yourself the ultimate cowgirl chic look. Top it off with a wide-brim hat, layered silver jewellery, and a hint of attitude, and now all we need is a horse!
It’s not always about the label but how confidently you wear the look. So if Frye has your heart but not your wallet, these dupes will save your day without sacrificing the style. Your next favorite boots are just a click away.
More Dupes:
